Has a Shibuya restaurant solved the problem of one of Japan’s most divisive soba noodle toppings?

18:13 cherishe 0 Comments

Soba-loving Seiji finds something that people who love croquette soba will love, and people who hate croquette soba might love it too.

Pretty much everyone in Japan likes soba noodles, and pretty much everyone in Japan likes croquettes too. Sure, some people like them more than others do, but it’d be tough to find someone who flat-out dislikes either one of the broadly-loved staples.

However, while soba and croquettes are both widely well-liked, opinions get much more divided when you start talking about eating a croquette and soba noodles together.

On the surface, it seems like using a croquette as a soba topping shouldn’t ruffle anyone’s feathers. After all, if noodles and mixed tempura work perfectly fine with soba broth, why not a croquette, which is still within the same broad category of fried starchiness?

The problem, according to the anti-croquette soba camp, is that the flavors don’t mesh well. Soba broth is made from dashi (bonito stock) and soy sauce, an unmistakably classical Japanese flavor profile. Croquettes, on the other hand, come from Western cuisine, so while they’re often enjoyed with a similarly occidentally inspired Worcester-like sauce, letting a croquette soak in soba broth leads to a discordant result in which east doesn’t meet west so much as the two culinary traditions stare awkwardly at each other from across the room.

Taking all that into account, our Japanese-language reporter Seiji Nakazawa can very much understand why some people don’t like croquette soba, but he has no personal problem with it. So when he recently stopped into a branch of soba chain Shibua Soba in Tokyo’s Shibuya neighborhood and saw that they had croquette soba on the menu, he decided to order it, thinking it might give him something to recommend to fellow croquette soba fans.

To his surprise, it ended up giving him something to recommend to croquette soba haters too.

Why? Because that’s not just any regular old croquette he ordered…

…but a saba (mackerel) croquette!

Fish croquettes are pretty rare in Japan, but they’re a specialty of the town of Hidaka in Wakayama Prefecture. Wakayama is also famous for its ume (Japanese plum), and so Hidaka-style mackerel croquettes are made by marinating the fish in plum vinegar, then mixing it in with the mashed potato and deep-frying them.

This gives the mackerel croquette a much more traditional Japanese taste than a typical all-potato one, and that, in turn, helps bridge the gap between it and the soba broth. Again, Seiji likes croquette soba with orthodox croquettes too, but this mackerel croquette makes for an extremely harmonious combination, especially if you leave it in the broth long enough for the liquid to soak all the way through to its core.

You end up with something that will still totally satisfy croquette soba fans, but which also addresses the major complaint from people who don’t like croquette soba. Seiji is confident that whichever side of the debate someone usually finds themselves on, they’ll love this dish, and it has him wondering whether there might also be ways in the world to find common ground on other decisive topics, such as whether cats or dogs make the better pet, or whether chocolate snacks shaped like mushrooms or bamboo shoots are the superior sweet treat.

Currently, though, the mackerel croquette soba, as well as its udon noodle sibling, are available only at the Shibuya Dogenzaka branch of Shibu Soba, where they’re priced at 650 yen (US$4.10). Considering how, in Seiji’s estimation, this has the potential to be a hit with 100 percent of the people in Japan, though, hopefully it’ll spread to other locations in the chain soon.

Restaurant information
Shibu Soba (Shibuya Dogenzaka branch) / しぶそば(渋谷道玄坂店)
Address: Tokyo-to, Shibuya-ku, Dogenzaka 2-9-10
東京都渋谷区道玄坂2-9-10
Open 8 a.m.-11 p.m. (weekdays), 9 a.m.-10 p.m. (weekends, holidays)

Photos ©SoraNews24
● Want to hear about SoraNews24’s latest articles as soon as they’re published? Follow us on Facebook and Twitter!



Credit:

0 comments: